1. Home
  2. Research
  3. Trader lessons
  4. Swap and overnight financing, explained

Swap and overnight financing, explained

How overnight financing is charged, why one night counts three times, and why our trend-following rules were positive before financing and negative after.

Free tutorial 3 of 10 · Beginner · 5 min read · By Theoneste NZAKIZWANIMANA

What swap is

If you hold a leveraged CFD or forex position past your broker's daily cut-off, you pay a financing charge, usually called swap or rollover. On some instruments, at some times, one side may receive a small credit, but for most retail traders the rate paid is higher than the rate received. On crypto perpetual futures the equivalent is a funding payment exchanged between longs and shorts every few hours.

Spread is paid once per trade. Swap is paid once per night held. That single difference decides which kind of trader it hurts: short holds barely notice it, long holds can be wiped out by it.

How it is charged, and the triple night

  • Swap is charged on the full value of the position, not on the amount you risk.
  • It is charged at the broker's daily rollover (at the broker we used, 17:00 New York time).
  • One night a week usually counts three times to cover the weekend. Which night depends on the instrument and the broker: in our CFD research we charged forex three days on Wednesday nights, and metals, indices and oil three days on Friday nights. On synthetic indices the contract file did not say, so we assumed the worst case.
  • Rates differ by broker, instrument and direction, and change over time. Read your broker's swap table.

In our tests we used stated assumptions rather than one broker's table: 3% a year on forex, 6% on metals, indices and oil, and 25% on crypto CFDs, charged on longs and shorts alike.

The formula in R

EURUSD, 1 lot, held 3 nights at 3% a year

Price 1.10 (illustrative): position value = 100,000 x 1.10 = $110,000

Financing = 0.03 x 3 / 365 x $110,000 = $27.12

Stop 20 pips, so 1R = 20 x $10 = $200

Financing in R = $27.12 / $200 = about 0.136R

Spread at 0.6 pips = $6 = 0.03R, so financing here is more than four times the spread

Holding longer, with a stop at 1% of the price

Forex at 3% a year, 30 days: 0.03 x 30 / 365 / 0.01 = about 0.25R

Crypto CFD at 25% a year, 30 days, stop at 5% of the price: 0.25 x 30 / 365 / 0.05 = about 0.41R

Why our trend systems lost to financing

If the spread kills short holds, the obvious move is to hold longer with wider stops. We did that in our edge search and met the second cost.

  • Monthly time-series momentum (8 settings): +0.01R to +0.06R per trade before financing; financing cost 0.06R to 0.09R per trade, while spread cost only 0.004R to 0.007R. Every setting was negative after financing.
  • Daily Donchian breakouts paid 0.13R to 0.35R per trade in financing.
  • Cross-sectional momentum paid about 0.085R per trade.
  • The only pass in our 39-strategy assessment, a linear regression slope rule on Bitcoin's one-hour chart, made +0.316R per trade without financing. At 25% a year, financing cost 0.089R per trade, and its t on 2017-2023 fell to 1.94, under the 2.0 bar. It no longer passed.
  • On crypto perpetual futures, funding took 36% and 39% of the gross profit of the two trend families we tested, against 6% and 1% for fees and slippage.

Receiving financing is not automatically a strategy either. On perpetual futures we tested a funding-carry rule: short the coins with the highest funding, buy those with the lowest. It received about 0.0045R per trade in funding and paid about 0.0073R per trade in fees and slippage. The carry did not pay for the trading.

Check your own swap cost

  1. Find your broker's swap rate for the instrument and direction you trade, and which night is charged three times.
  2. Note your typical holding time in nights, and your stop as a fraction of the price.
  3. Compute financing in R with the formula above (or in money, then divide by 1R).
  4. Add it to your spread cost and compare the total with your average result per trade before costs.
  5. If you hold for weeks, rerun your backtest with financing charged on every night held.

Worked check for a crypto day trade

Crypto CFD held one night, stop at 2% of the price, 25% a year (illustration)

Financing in R = 0.25 x 1 / 365 / 0.02 = about 0.034R for one night

Held over a weekend at a broker that charges every day: about 3 x 0.034 = about 0.10R

The one pass in our library assessment held its median trade about 23 hours and paid about 0.089R per trade

Limits

The middle ground does not rescue things either: on indices, one- to five-day holds paid only about 0.005R in spread and 0.005R in financing, but the reversal rules we tested there made at most about +0.008R per trade before costs.

Key takeaways

  • Swap is charged on the full position value, every night held, with one night usually counted three times.
  • Financing in R grows with holding time and with tighter stops.
  • Our monthly trend rules were positive before financing and negative after it in every setting.
  • Short holds lose to the spread, long holds to financing: there is no free holding period.

Education only, not investment advice. Results quoted from TradeLab research are historical simulations; trading can lose more than you expect.

Check a strategy before you risk money on it

Send us your bot or strategy and get an independent report that uses your broker's costs.

What to send us

  • The bot files: an MT5 expert advisor, Python code or written rules
  • The markets and timeframes it trades
  • Your broker, so the test uses its spreads and financing
Email your bot