1. Home
  2. Research
  3. Trader lessons
  4. What the spread really costs you

What the spread really costs you

Turn the spread from pips into R and see why scalping pays several times more per trade than swing trading. Real numbers from broker data.

Free tutorial 2 of 10 · Beginner · 5 min read · By Theoneste NZAKIZWANIMANA

The cost you pay on every trade

You buy at the ask and sell at the bid. The ask is always higher, and the difference is the spread. You pay it once on every round trip, win or lose. It does not show on most charts, and many backtests ignore it or use one flattering number. In our research it was the single biggest reason trading rules failed.

We tested 39 classic strategies (EMA crossovers, RSI, MACD, Bollinger bands, breakouts, pin bars and more) on broker data from 2017 to 2026 with the spread recorded at each fill. Before the spread, 16 of the 39 had a positive average trade. After the spread, 3 did.

Convert the spread into R

A spread of 0.6 pips sounds tiny. What matters is its size compared with what you risk on the trade. Measure it in R, where 1R is the amount you lose if your stop is hit:

Stop distanceCost at 0.6 pips (median)Cost at 0.8 pips (90th percentile)
3 pips0.20R0.27R
5 pips0.12R0.16R
10 pips0.06R0.08R
20 pips0.03R0.04R
50 pips0.012R0.016R

These spreads are the EURUSD median and 90th percentile we measured at our broker since 2024. The 90th percentile is the spread you pay one trade in ten, or worse: in quiet hours, around news and at the daily rollover.

The same arithmetic applies on every market, in its own units. Gold's median spread at our broker was $0.18 with a 90th percentile of $0.41, so a scalp with a $2 stop pays about 0.09R at the median and about 0.2R when the spread is wide. On the US100 index, a 1.8-point median spread on a 20-point stop is about 0.09R.

Worked example: scalp versus swing

Two EURUSD traders, 100 trades each, 0.6-pip spread

Scalper: 5-pip stop. Spread per trade = 0.6 / 5 = 0.12R

Over 100 trades: 100 x 0.12R = 12R paid in spread

Swing trader: 50-pip stop. Spread per trade = 0.6 / 50 = 0.012R

Over 100 trades: 100 x 0.012R = 1.2R paid in spread

The scalper must earn 0.12R per trade before costs just to break even; the swing trader needs 0.012R

Our 39-strategy assessment showed the same effect on real rules: the median strategy paid 0.128R per trade in spread on the 15-minute chart and 0.057R on the one-hour chart. Only 3 of 113 fifteen-minute tests had a positive average after costs, against 17 of 110 one-hour tests.

What the spread did to a real rule

The clearest case in our edge search was a rule that traded small reversals in currency pairs during the Asian session. Before costs, all 12 of its settings made money: +0.04R to +0.11R per trade. It paid 0.14R to 0.22R per trade in spread (about 0.16R on EURUSD and GBPUSD, 0.20R to 0.21R on AUDUSD and GBPJPY). After costs, all 12 lost: -0.07R to -0.17R per trade.

At -0.07R per trade, every 100 trades cost 7R. Trading more does not fix a negative average; it only adds the losses up faster. We also checked cheaper account types: raw-spread accounts at large retail brokers cost roughly the same all-in on EURUSD, about 0.6 to 0.8 pips including a commission of about $3 to $3.50 per lot per side. This rule would have needed its costs cut to about a third.

How to measure your own spread cost

  1. Find the real spread at the hours you trade: your broker's tick or minute data, or the spread on your own fills. Note a typical value and a wide one (the 90th percentile if you can get it).
  2. Take your typical stop distance in the same units.
  3. Divide spread by stop. That is your spread cost per trade in R. Add commission, converted the same way.
  4. Compare it with your average result per trade before costs. If the cost is close to the edge, the strategy has nothing left to pay you with.
  5. Stress it: multiply the spread by 1.5 and check the average stays positive. Every result in our research had to pass this test.
  6. Check your data: our broker's export recorded zero spread for 12% of Bitcoin minutes. Missing spreads make a backtest look free.

When spreads are widest

  • Quiet sessions. The Asian-session rule above paid its widest spreads on AUDUSD and GBPJPY.
  • The daily rollover. Around the broker's daily break, spreads can widen sharply.
  • News. Spreads often widen around major releases, exactly when many short-term rules want to trade.
  • Thin instruments. Gold's 90th-percentile spread was more than double its median in our data.

A strategy trades when its signal fires, not when the spread is at its best. If your signals cluster at any of these moments, your real cost is closer to the wide end than to the median.

Limits

Other measured medians, with the 90th percentile in brackets: GBPUSD 0.9 pips (1.2), AUDUSD 0.8 pips (1.0), gold $0.18 ($0.41), US100 1.8 points. Use them as a sense of scale, then measure your own.

Key takeaways

  • Spread cost in R = spread / stop distance: tight stops make the same spread far more expensive.
  • In our tests, 16 of 39 classic strategies were positive before the spread and 3 after it.
  • A scalp with a 5-pip stop pays about ten times more spread per trade, in R, than a swing trade with a 50-pip stop.
  • Measure the spread at your own trading hours and stress-test at 1.5 x.

Education only, not investment advice. Results quoted from TradeLab research are historical simulations; trading can lose more than you expect.

Check a strategy before you risk money on it

Send us your bot or strategy and get an independent report that uses your broker's costs.

What to send us

  • The bot files: an MT5 expert advisor, Python code or written rules
  • The markets and timeframes it trades
  • Your broker, so the test uses its spreads and financing
Email your bot